Nobody could say exactly when it started. Toby himself couldn’t tell you. What he could tell you — at length, if you let him — was that a black pearl is not merely a pearl that happens to be black. It is something else entirely. Something rare. Something that understands.
The first one came from an antique market in Hackney, 2019. A woman selling costume jewellery didn’t know what she had. Toby did. He paid two pounds for it and walked home very carefully, the pearl wrapped in a receipt in his breast pocket, his hand pressed against his chest the whole way.
He kept it on his bedside table. He still does.
The collection grows
By 2021, he had eleven. He knew each one by feel — the weight, the specific coolness, the way the surface caught light differently depending on the angle. He could identify them blind. He had tested this.
His flatmate at the time, a phlegmatic man named Phil, noticed the pearls but said nothing for several months. Eventually, at a house party, Phil mentioned to someone that Toby had “a bit of a pearl thing.” Toby heard this from across the room and did not speak to Phil again for three weeks.
The jar appeared around this time. A large glass apothecary jar, sealed with a cork, which Toby placed on the windowsill of the sitting room. He said it was aesthetic. Phil said nothing.
The problem, if you could call it that
Here is the thing about Toby: he is perfectly normal in every other respect. He has a job in project management. He goes to the gym three times a week. He cooks. He calls his mother on Sundays. He once spent an entire weekend helping a friend move flats and didn’t complain once.
But if you pick up one of his pearls without asking — just casually, the way you might pick up any object in someone’s home — something happens to Toby’s face. It’s subtle. He doesn’t say anything. He doesn’t need to.
You put the pearl down.
The current count
Toby won’t give you an exact number. “Quite a few,” he says. Friends who have been to his flat estimate somewhere between sixty and two hundred, depending on how many rooms they were allowed into. The bedroom, at some point, became off-limits to guests.
He does not consider himself a collector. “Collectors acquire things for their value,” he said once. “I’m not interested in value.”
He paused.
“Well. Not monetary value.”
What Toby says about it
When pressed — and you do have to press — Toby becomes thoughtful. He talks about the way black pearls form: an irritant, layer by layer, over years. He talks about nacre. He talks about how most pearls are bleached or dyed and how you can tell if you know what you’re looking for. He talks about the deep-sea molluscs that produce them, the Pinctada margaritifera, which he has looked into getting.
He hasn’t yet. But he’s looked into it.
“I just think they’re extraordinary,” he says, and there is something in his expression that closes the subject. Not defensively. Just finally.
You don’t push further. You have another cup of tea. You are careful, on the way out, not to brush against the shelf in the hallway.
The pearls on that shelf don’t fall easily. But still.
This is a work of fiction. Any resemblance to actual pearl enthusiasts, living or dead, is unintentional and would frankly be concerning.
Thanks for reading this 100% hand-written post! Follow me on LinkedIn for more or check out my projects.